Can I Get A Do-Over?
When you are a promising young player from a family with a historically good pedigree it seems impossible to mess up your career, doesn’t it? I mean, your father was a legend at Ole Miss and a successful pro. Your older brother might go down as the best quarterback to ever play the game. Seems like you got it made in the shade. And actually, you had it made in the San Diego shade, but you didn’t want to play there. You wanted to play anywhere but there because you felt that organization didn't run things so well (3 years after it dealt you away they were 14-2 and coming off its second AFC West Championship). So you demanded to be traded before you signed a deal with the Chargers and here you are in New York. Smart move. You demanded a trade from a city that barely booed Ryan Leaf to a city that launches the boobirds at Alex Rodriguez relentlessly. You are Eli Manning and it looks like you made a big old mistake on draft day three years ago.
It began to be floated around last year that Eli Manning made a large mistake on draft day 2004. But now with Tiki Barber retired I think about how his decision seems to get worse by the minute. He could be handing the ball off to LaDanian Tomlinson, perhaps the best football player ever, instead, he’ll be handing off to Brandon Jacobs (who?) if the Giants don’t land a back in the draft or make a trade.
Not to mention the fact that the Eli deal has made the Chargers into one of the premiere teams in the league. They not only landed current quarterback Phillip Rivers but also the most disruptive defensive player in football in Shawne Merriman in return for giving up Manning. (Merriman came from the 2005 pick the Giants dealt the Chargers to get Manning).
And then I heard the most awful words that I could hear for the sake of Eli Manning the other day. An ESPN analyst (and I’m not sure who because I wasn’t paying that close of attention) said, “the Giants offense is squarely on Eli’s shoulders.” Not exactly what you want to hear in New York when you have a career 73.2 passer rating.
I’m not saying that Eli is bad at all. He has a lot of potential and a great chance to be something, but I don’t think New York is the best place for him to try to do that. In New York they boo the guy that is the reigning AL MVP after he strikes out once, that guy might be the best baseball player to lace them up. If they can boo him, I have no doubt they will be quick to boo an average quarterback for making average mistakes.
Hindsight, for right now, says Eli made a bit of a mistake. If only we could get do-overs in real life.
